via I-95
The drive from New York to Nantucket takes approximately 4h 42min, covering 259 miles via I-95. Under normal conditions, expect to spend around $30 on gas.
Travel time can vary — during peak hours, weekends, or holidays, the journey may take 6–7+ hours. For the fastest trip, leave early morning (before 7 AM) or travel on weekday evenings.
Traffic is usually worst during weekday rush hours (7–9 AM, 4–7 PM) and holiday weekends.
One of the busiest highways on the East Coast. Expect congestion near major cities like New York, Philadelphia, and Washington DC.
This trip can typically be done on a single tank of gas.
The best time to drive from New York to Nantucket is late evening (8-10 pm). Weekday mornings before 7 AM or evenings after 7 PM typically have the lightest traffic. Avoid Friday afternoons and Sunday evenings when possible.
✈️ Flying is faster when you factor in airport time. Flight time is ~31 min but add ~2.5 hours for check-in, security, and boarding.
Estimated times and prices. Bus/train availability varies by route. Driving gives the most flexibility for stops and schedules.
Popular cities along the route for rest, food, or fuel:
The journey from New York to Nantucket stretches 259 miles along I-95 and typically takes 4h 42min to complete. At today's fuel prices, expect to spend around $30 on gas. Departing during late evening (8-10 pm) gives you the best chance of avoiding congestion along the way.
The 259-mile distance makes this a proper road trip. Start with a full tank, grab a coffee for the road, and enjoy the changing scenery as you make your way from New York to Nantucket. Popular stopping points include Hamptons, New Haven, Newport — great options for grabbing a meal, fueling up, or stretching your legs.